Crown vs Filling: Pros and Cons of Restorative Dental Options

dentist choosing dental between crown vs filling

When restoring damaged or decayed teeth, two common options are dental crowns and dental fillings. These restorative treatments have advantages and disadvantages and the choice between them depends on several factors.

What Is a Dental Crown?

A dental crown is a custom-made cap placed over a damaged or weakened tooth. It covers the entire visible portion of the tooth, restoring its shape, size, strength, and appearance. Crowns can be made from various materials, including porcelain, metal alloys, or both.

Advantages of Dental Crowns

  • Improved confidence. Dental crowns are an excellent choice for enhancing the appearance of a tooth and improving the overall smile, which can boost self-esteem and confidence.
  • Versatility. Dental crowns can address dental issues, such as covering dental implants, protecting weak teeth from further damage, or restoring teeth after root canal treatment.
  • Easy maintenance. Crowns are relatively easy to maintain and can be cared for like natural teeth, with regular brushing, flossing, and dental check-ups.
  • Customizable. Dental crowns can be customized in size, shape, and color to match your specific dental needs and preferences, resulting in a seamless and personalized restoration.
  • Natural functionality. A dental crown works like a natural or functional tooth, allowing for normal speech and proper biting and chewing, contributing to oral health.
  • Preserve the tooth. Instead of extracting severely damaged or decayed teeth, dental crowns can preserve the remaining healthy tooth structure, preventing more invasive treatments like dental implants or bridges.
  • Improved speech. Crowns can restore the shape and alignment of teeth, improving speech and pronunciation, especially if the damage or decay has affected the front teeth.
  • Cost-effective. Dental crowns are a cost-effective solution for extensive dental damage or decay, as they can help avoid more expensive treatments in the long run.
  • Non-invasive. Dental crown placement is a non-invasive procedure that does not require significant alterations to the natural tooth structure, making it a conservative approach to dental restoration.

Disadvantages of Dental Crowns

  • Invasive procedure. Crown placement requires removing a significant amount of natural tooth structure, which may not be ideal for individuals with healthy teeth.
  • Additional visits. Getting a dental crown involves multiple visits to the dentist’s office, as the procedure requires the fabrication of a custom crown.
  • Higher cost. Dental crown procedures tend to be more expensive than dental fillings due to the materials used and the complexity of the dental procedure.
  • Metal allergies. Some individuals may have allergies or sensitivities to certain metal alloys used in crowns, making them unsuitable for those patients.

What Is a Filling?

A tooth filling is a common solution for treating minor tooth decay or cavities. It involves removing the decayed portion of the tooth and filling the resulting space with a suitable material, such as composite resin, silver amalgam, or gold.

Advantages of Dental Fillings:

  • Conservative treatment. Dental fillings require minimal removal of natural tooth structure, making them a more conservative option for treating minor tooth decay.
  • Quick procedure. Filling placement can often be completed in a single dental visit, saving time and reducing the need for multiple appointments.
  • Cost-effective. Compared to dental crowns, fillings are generally more affordable, making them an ideal choice for individuals seeking a budget-friendly option.
  • Aesthetic benefits. Composite resin fillings can be color-matched to your natural tooth enamel, providing a seamless and natural-looking restoration.

Disadvantages of Dental Fillings

  • Limited coverage. A tooth filling may not be suitable for larger areas of decay or extensive damage, as they do not provide the same level of protection as crowns.
  • Potential for future decay. Fillings may need to be replaced over time, especially if the surrounding tooth structure becomes compromised or additional decay occurs.
  • Less structural support. While fillings restore the tooth’s functionality, they do not offer the same structural support as dental crowns.
  • Aesthetic concerns. Silver amalgam fillings can be visible when smiling or laughing, potentially impacting the appearance of your smile.

Filling Vs Crown: What Are Their Differences?

1. Purpose

  • Dental crowns: Crowns cover a damaged or decayed tooth, providing protection and restoring its shape, size, strength, and appearance.
  • Dental fillings: Fillings fill in small to medium-sized cavities caused by tooth decay, restoring the tooth’s function and preventing further decay.

2. Material

  • Dental crowns: Crowns are typically made from materials such as porcelain, ceramic, metal alloys, or a combination of materials to provide strength and durability.
  • Dental fillings: Fillings are commonly made from materials like composite resin, amalgam (a mixture of metals), or gold.

3. Tooth Preparation

  • Dental crowns: To place a crown, the tooth is reshaped by removing a significant portion of its structure to accommodate the crown.
  • Dental fillings: Fillings require minimal tooth preparation, with only the decayed part of the tooth being removed.

4. Strength and Durability

  • Dental crowns: Crowns offer superior strength and durability, making them suitable for heavily damaged or weakened teeth.
  • Dental fillings: Fillings are less durable and are more prone to wear and tear, making them ideal for smaller cavities or less stressed areas of the mouth.

5. Aesthetics

  • Dental crowns: Crowns can be customized to match the color, shape, and size of the surrounding teeth, providing a natural-looking appearance.
  • Dental fillings: Fillings are available in tooth-colored materials, but they may not perfectly match the natural color of the tooth.

6. Cost

  • Dental crowns: Crowns tend to be more expensive than fillings due to the additional materials and laboratory costs.
  • Dental fillings: Fillings are generally more affordable than crowns.

7. Longevity

  • Dental crowns: With proper care, dental crowns can last many years, typically 10-15 years or even longer.
  • Dental fillings: Fillings have a shorter lifespan than crowns, usually lasting around 5-10 years.

Factors Affecting Your Decision in Choosing Between Dental Crowns and Fillings

The choice between a dental crown and a dental filling depends on several factors, including:

  • Extent of tooth damage. Dental crowns are typically recommended for larger areas of decay or severe tooth damage, while fillings are suitable for minor to moderate cavities.
  • Tooth structure. If a tooth has been significantly weakened or lacks sufficient natural structure, a crown may be necessary to provide support.
  • Aesthetic concerns. For individuals who prioritize a natural-looking, healthy smile, porcelain crowns or composite resin fillings may be the preferred choice.
  • Financial considerations. The cost of treatment can play a role in decision-making. While dental fillings are generally more affordable, crowns offer greater longevity and durability.
  • Recommendation of the dentist. Your dentist will assess your specific dental needs and recommend the most appropriate treatment option based on their expertise and oral health status.

Choose the Right Restoration Option With Olympic View Dental

Dental crowns and dental fillings serve as effective solutions for tooth restoration. Dental crowns provide enhanced protection, durability, and aesthetic benefits, making them suitable for severe tooth decay or damaged teeth. On the other hand, dental fillings offer a more conservative and cost-effective option for minor tooth decay.

The decision between a crown and a filling depends on factors such as the extent of tooth decay, the condition of the tooth, aesthetic concerns, and financial considerations. It is important to consult with a dental professional who can assess your specific needs and recommend the most suitable restorative option for you.

Crowns and fillings require proper care and regular check-ups to maintain longevity and ensure optimal oral health. If you have any further questions or concerns, or whether you’re contemplating when do you need a crown vs filling, contact Olympic View Dental for personalized advice!


Cosmetic Dentist in Seattle

We are open:

Mon-Thurs: 8:00am – 5:00pm, Fri: Appointment Only
For additional questions you can call us at 206-824-4700 or you can find us on Yelp.

We proudly serve Seattle, Tacoma, Burien, Des Moines, Federal Way, Sea Tac and surrounding areas.